The Prognosis, Green Room Theatre, Dorking
24th October 2026

I came across The Prognosis' Still Waters in a box of pre-loved LPs in a flea market in Brighton, without knowing anything about the band. The cover and the group's name suggested they were prog, which I confirmed with a check on progarchives.com and though the album wasn’t rated terribly well, I still handed I handed over my cash for a near-perfect condition piece of vinyl.
Following my acquisition and subsequent enjoyment of the music, I thought I’d set the record straight on Progarchives with my own review. This entailed a bit of research, which led to my discovery that The Prognosis had been voted 'Best Unsigned Band' in the 2013 Prog magazine readers' poll and the January 2014 edition of the magazine, Prog 42, featured the band in a two-page spread. At that point they'd released a small amount of self-penned material (the Under Box Hill EP, 2013) and it wouldn't be until 2018 that they'd put out Still Waters.
I’d noticed that the band had played at the Dorking Festival and as I’d recently started to frequent some of the towns in the Surrey Hills (I used to climb the local landmark Box Hill a long time ago, when I was single), I thought it would be well worth going to see them when I chanced upon an advert for the gig: a 'home town' show held in Dorking's Green Room Theatre, an intimate but impressive space behind the Dorking Halls with a low stage, raked seating for 86, and highly regarded acoustics.
Attending on the second of two consecutive nights, the theatre was filled to capacity. But before filing into the cosy auditorium, I took a look at the merchandise stand. It turned out that The Prognosis had released a new album on digital platforms in summer 2025, called Runs Deep. This was featured in its entirety during the performance and I picked up a copy of the LP from the merchandise desk.
The band - Nelson Porter (guitar), Richard Flanders (bass, vocals), Simon Gardner (guitar, vocals), Ian Twentyman (keyboards), and Grant Harrison (drums, vocals) - were supplemented by Robert McEvoy on flute, Chris South on alto sax and Annabelle South on saxophones, flute and harp, providing a full sound; the Souths, who perform together as woodwind-centric jazzy folk duo Meles Lutra, played one of their own tracks, Seven Stones during the first set.
The Prognosis had started out as a tribute act playing classic prog from the 70s and 80s, so it wasn't too surprising when the show opened with Pink Floyd's Time/Breathe Reprise, and we were also treated to Harrison coming to the front of the stage to deliver an excellent version of Peter Gabriel's Here Comes The Flood, and later, some instrument swapping for the 1999 song Even Less by Porcupine Tree, with Flanders taking on shredding duties.
The Still Waters telling of local folklore (Topsy-Turvy, The Silent Pool), reminiscent of early Genesis, has largely been replaced by more observational lyrics reflecting current issues like dark web scams and being bombarded with rolling news, written with the help of Martin Day, though local matters hadn’t been abandoned entirely; Zig Zag, played as the encore, is a song about the cycle route up Box Hill, popularised by the London 2012 Olympics. While the new music shows broader influences, including the slick music of Steely Dan, but there's still plenty of genuine prog in the band, which includes their worldview, indicated by releasing the new LP on plant-based 'vinyl', and adding their support to the music industry’s climate foundation, EarthPercent (co-founded by Brian Eno.)
It was an enjoyable gig, well attended despite some biblical weather, where a number of carefully negotiated metrical challenges demonstrated the skills of the musicians, in a lovely venue with a well-balanced sound.